The Fox News late-night show Gutfeld!—long praised for its unconventional humor and political satire—has recently found itself at the center of a growing controversy, not over politics, but over one of its regular contributors: George “Tyrus” Murdoch. Once a fan-favorite for his unique background and imposing stage presence, Tyrus is now facing intense criticism from viewers who claim he’s hijacking the show and turning it into “an unwatchable mess.”

Social media and comment sections have erupted in recent weeks with messages like:

“I turn off the TV as soon as Tyrus shows up!”
“He talks over everyone. The show used to be clever—now it’s just noise.”
“Gutfeld needs to rein him in or risk losing his core audience.”

So what exactly is going on, and why is the backlash reaching a boiling point?

From Fan Favorite to Focal Point of Frustration

Tyrus, a former professional wrestler and Fox News contributor, was originally welcomed onto Gutfeld! as a refreshing and unconventional presence. His offbeat humor and confident demeanor provided an entertaining contrast to the more traditional pundits on the panel. For a while, his popularity soared.

But many long-time fans now say the balance has tipped—and not in a good way.

Critics argue that Tyrus dominates conversations, derails punchlines, and often steers discussions off-topic with awkward tangents. Instead of enhancing the show’s rhythm, they claim he’s become a major disruption to it.

“It’s like he thinks he’s the host,” said one YouTube commenter. “He interrupts Greg, outtalks Kat, and ignores the format entirely.”

On Reddit and Facebook groups dedicated to conservative media, posts asking for Tyrus to be removed or limited in airtime are gaining traction. Even some casual viewers say they’ve started skipping episodes altogether.

What Fans Are Really Saying

While every show has its critics, the volume and consistency of the anti-Tyrus feedback is notable. In the last two months alone, several Twitter threads with thousands of likes and retweets have demanded his removal—or at least a format shake-up.

Common complaints include:

• Interruptions and talking over others

• Lack of comedic timing

• Overuse of inside jokes that don’t land

• Monologues that feel out of place or self-serving

“Tyrus used to add flavor,” said one longtime fan on X. “Now he’s the entire meal, and nobody ordered it.”

Gutfeld Stays Silent—For Now

So far, Greg Gutfeld has not publicly commented on the criticism, nor has Fox News released a statement. However, media insiders suggest the network is well aware of the backlash. A source close to the production team hinted that “internal conversations” are ongoing about the show’s direction heading into fall 2025.

Meanwhile, co-panelists like Kat Timpf and guests like Tom Shillue have appeared visibly frustrated on-air during Tyrus’s longer rants, prompting viewers to post reaction clips captioned, “You can see Kat dying inside.”

Some speculate that the growing tension might eventually force a retooling of the show’s guest lineup or format.

The Bigger Problem: Losing the Show’s Identity?

Beyond individual personalities, fans worry the show is drifting from what made it unique in the first place. Gutfeld! broke the mold by blending news commentary with sharp, fast-paced humor. But lately, many say the pace has slowed—and the wit has dulled.

“This used to be the only late-night show I’d watch,” lamented one viewer. “Now it feels like a podcast with no direction.”

In an increasingly competitive media landscape, especially with the rise of conservative comedy podcasts and YouTube personalities, Gutfeld! can’t afford to alienate its loyal base.

What’s Next?

As of July 2025, the show continues to air with Tyrus in his regular slot. But if the outrage continues to grow, pressure may mount for Gutfeld and producers to make changes—or risk a steady decline in viewership.

Fans are making their voices heard, and they want the old Gutfeld! back: punchy, sharp, and well-paced.

Whether the show listens remains to be seen. But one thing is clear—when your audience starts turning off the TV because of a single personality, it’s no longer just noise. It’s a warning.